DIY Photography

Your one stop shop for everything photo-video

  • News
  • Inspiration
  • Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • DIY
  • Gear
Search

Submit A Story

Comparing Eight 200mm Lenses Yields Interesting Results

Mar 27, 2015 by Udi Tirosh 10 Comments

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

200mm-lenses-battle

If you are an action, wedding, portraiture or a nature photographer you probably have (or want) a 200mm lens, either at fixed focal length or one that can zoom all the way to that spot.

It should also not surprise you that not all 200mm lenses are born equal. While weight, compatibility, stabilization and price may all play a factor, sometimes it all comes down to optics. Roger Cicala and Aaron Closz of Lensrentals compared 8 (yea, eight) different lenses at 200 and shares the results, optically speaking.

First here is a list to the eight tested lenses:

  • Canon 200mm f/2.8 L Mk II
  • Canon 70-200 f/2.8 NON IS
  • Canon 70-200 f/2.8 IS II
  • Canon 200mm f/2.0 IS L
  • Nikon 70-200 f/2.8 AF-S VR II
  • Nikon 200mm f/2.0 ED AF-S VR II
  • Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 EX DG HSM OS
  • Tamron 70-200 f/2.8 SP Di VC

Those vary in price range and in being a prime or a zoom lens that goes up to 200mm.

The methodology

This is something quite interesting, Lensrentals did not mount the lenses onto cameras to test them, but rather they used a device that can test the lenses with no relations to a camera:

[Lensrentals] take advantage of our Trioptics Imagemaster optical bench to compare lenses from different camera mounts with no camera involved. Why is that different? Because all other forms of testing (DxO, Imatest, or even photography) tests the camera-lens combination. Sensor architecture, micro lenses, in-camera image processing and other things affect those results. A third-party lens on a Canon 5DIII will have different results than the same lens on a Nikon D800 for example.

IMG_1097-768x1024

The Results

Of course the most interesting test would be the Nikon vs Nikon test, and you can see the results below. Roger is using industry standard MTF maps. If you are unfamiliar with MTF, here is a great primer.

legend 200f2comp-1024x736

both of these lenses are really superb, the verdict is that: “These are both awesomely superb lenses and looking for differences between them is really just hair splitting.“, and if you care for the small nitpicking, you can check the full blog over at Lensrentals.

Looking at the Zooms now, again both Nikon and Canon are darn good lenses.

70-200canik-1024x748 Nik200comp-1024x748 can200comp-1024x748

It is only when Roger compared Zooms vs. Primes we see that the prime lenses do perform better, though the zooms are still quite awesome. In fact Roger shares that the latest zooms function better than his old prime.

Lastly, Roger turns an eye for third party lenses, and you know what, they are not that bad. And the cost may play a significant factor.

thirdpartycomp-1024x708

Of course, as Roger points out, choosing a lens should have more to do than resolution:

A lot of people use their 70-200mm lenses largely at 200mm, so resolution at that focal length is a big factor. But there’s a lot more to choosing the proper lens for the task than resolution at 200mm, of course. In reality things like fast and accurate autofocus, especially for sports shooters, is probably more important than absolute resolution.

The cost of 200mm lenses varies greatly and is certainly a big factor when people decide which lens they want. The Canon and Nikon 200mm f/2.0 lenses are nearly $6,000, while their image stabilized 70-200mm f/2.8 zooms are over $2,000.  The Canon 70-200 f/2.8 NON IS is about $1,500, as is the Tamron zoom. The Sigma 70-200 is about $1,200 and the Canon L prime is the bargain of the bunch at about $800.

If one just considers price and resolution then the third party lenses, which are also image stabilized, certainly offer some advantages over the Canon NON IS lens. The Sigma price is more attractive than the Tamron and the Sigma arguably is a sharper lens in the lab. (Again, I emphasize that rapid and accurate autofocus may be more important than absolute resolution at 200mm.)

My opinion, though, is that the extra cost involved in getting the brand-name zoom lens in this category is probably worth it if you can possibly manage it. The Canon and Nikon f2.8 stabilized zooms are amazing optics. The f/2.0 primes, while wonderful lenses and even better optically than the zooms, are priced like the specialty items they are. The third-party lenses and Canon Non IS are cheaper, and probably good enough for many uses. But don’t kid yourself; they aren’t as good

[Just the Lenses: The Great 200mm Shoot Out | Lensrentals]

FIND THIS INTERESTING? SHARE IT WITH YOUR FRIENDS!

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Related posts:

Comparing eight popular lenses and how they affect your portraits Applying Photoshop’s Dehaze On a Haze-Free Image Yields Spectacular Results Shooting an abandoned building with a pinhole camera yields magical images The Tamron 70-210mm f/4 goes up against the new Canon 70-200mm f/4 IS II and Nikon 70-200mm f/4 VR

Filed Under: Gear Tagged With: 200mm, gear comparison, Lenses

Udi Tirosh: from diyphotography.net

About Udi Tirosh

Udi Tirosh is an entrepreneur, photography inventor, journalist, educator, and writer based in Israel. With over 25 years of experience in the photo-video industry, Udi has built and sold several photography-related brands. Udi has a double degree in mass media communications and computer science.

« A New Law Allows Indiana Photographers to Refuse Same-Sex Clients
Thought You Can Use Amazon’s Unlimited Storage Plan for Your Business? Think Again »

Submit A Story

Get our FREE Lighting Book

DIYP lighting book cover

* download requires newsletter signup
DIYPhotography

Recent Comments

Free Resources

Advanced lighting book

Recent Posts

  • Comparing iPhone 13 vs iPhone 14 for astrophotography
  • Don’t buy a Z8 directly from Nikon, customers say
  • YouTube is killing off “Stories” to focus on Shorts and Live
  • Four ways to shoot epic stop motion hyperlapse with a smartphone gimbal
  • Canon reported to be working on a “zoomable” teleconverter

Udi Tirosh: from diyphotography.netUdi Tirosh is an entrepreneur, photography inventor, journalist, educator, and writer based in Israel. With over 25 years of experience in the photo-video industry, Udi has built and sold several photography-related brands. Udi has a double degree in mass media communications and computer science.

Alex Baker: from diyphotography.netAlex Baker is a portrait and lifestyle driven photographer based in Valencia, Spain. She works on a range of projects from commercial to fine art and has had work featured in publications such as The Daily Mail, Conde Nast Traveller and El Mundo, and has exhibited work across Europe

David Williams: from diyphotography.netDave Williams is an accomplished travel photographer, writer, and best-selling author from the UK. He is also a photography educator and published Aurora expert. Dave has traveled extensively in recent years, capturing stunning images from around the world in a modified van. His work has been featured in various publications and he has worked with notable brands such as Skoda, EE, Boeing, Huawei, Microsoft, BMW, Conde Nast, Electronic Arts, Discovery, BBC, The Guardian, ESPN, NBC, and many others.

John Aldred: from diyphotography.netJohn Aldred is a photographer with over 20 years of experience in the portrait and commercial worlds. He is based in Scotland and has been an early adopter - and occasional beta tester - of almost every digital imaging technology in that time. As well as his creative visual work, John uses 3D printing, electronics and programming to create his own photography and filmmaking tools and consults for a number of brands across the industry.

Dunja Djudjic: from diyphotography.netDunja Djudjic is a multi-talented artist based in Novi Sad, Serbia. With 15 years of experience as a photographer, she specializes in capturing the beauty of nature, travel, and fine art. In addition to her photography, Dunja also expresses her creativity through writing, embroidery, and jewelry making.

Copyright © DIYPhotography 2006 - 2023 | About | Contact | Advertise | Write for DIYP | Full Disclosure | Privacy Policy