DIY Photography

Your one stop shop for everything photo-video

  • News
  • Inspiration
  • Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • DIY
  • Gear
Search

Submit A Story

Should AI-generated pictures win “Creative” categories of photo contests?

Apr 7, 2023 by Dunja Djudjic 21 Comments

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Sony World Photography Awards recently published the winners and shortlists of its Open competition. The photos are absolutely stunning, but there’s just one problem – the Creative category winner isn’t a photo at all. The winning image resembles a portrait photo from the 1940s, with a characteristic vintage, nostalgic feel. But on a closer look, you can spot the weird hands – one of the biggest weaknesses of text-to-image generators.

This case sparked some serious debate in the photo community. It also made me think about AI and its place in photography. Should AI-generated art enter and win photography contests? Is it fair? Are there legal issues? I wanted to discuss all of this and more in this article.

[Related reading: Why AI is a threat to the photography industry]

The backstory

The winner of the Creative category of this year’s Sony World Photography Awards is Boris Eldagsen with his AI-generated image PSEUDOMNESIA | The Electrician. To be clear, Boris is a photographer with over two decades of medium experience, so he knows his craft. Also, he fully disclosed that it was an AI image he submitted to SWPA, and he didn’t try to pass it as photography.

“I have been photographing since 1989, been a photomedia artist since 2000. After two decades of photography, my artistic focus has shifted to exploring the creative possibilities of AI generators.

The work SWPA has chosen is the result of a complex interplay of prompt engineering, inpainting and outpainting that draws on my wealth of photographic knowledge. For me, working with AI image generators is a co-creation, in which I am the director. It is not about pressing a button – and done it is. It is about exploring the complexity of this process, starting with refining text prompts, then developing a complex workflow, and mixing various platforms and techniques. The more you create such a workflow and define parameters, the higher your creative part becomes.”

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by ProfiFoto (@profifoto.de)

It’s worth noting that Boris explained his process behind this image before the winners were selected. This means his win wasn’t the jury’s oversight but a conscious decision.

Previous cases of AI-generated images winning photo contests

As you might already know, this wasn’t the first time something like this had happened. The first time (that we know of) was in September 2022, which sparked an outrage in the photo community. Then it happened again earlier this year, but it turned out that it was a marketing stunt.

Potential issues

Other than public outrage, AI-generated images winning photography contests can lead to a series of other issues.

Legal issues

First and foremost, cases like this cancel out the copyright policy of all photography contests. When you enter your image into any contest, your entry must not contain any copyrighted material owned by third parties.” And in the case of AI-generated images, this is a major grey area.

On the one hand, text-to-image generators like Midjourney create images based on everything they learned by training. And of course, they learned from photos other people took. They don’t generate a direct composite of other people’s photos. However, they still rely on them for the result – and we could debate if this is okay regarding “copyrighted material owned by third parties.”

On the other hand, there’s the issue of protecting your own AI-generated work. According to the US government, this type of work doesn’t fall under copyright protection. This means that anyone can use your image as they please, and you won’t get compensated.

Needless to say, I made this in Midjourney.

Lack of clear guidelines

As Profi Foto notes, SWPA’s FAQ is silent regarding the submission of AI-generated images to the contest. They’re neither banned nor encouraged; they’re not even mentioned. This leaves much room for doubt and uncertainties, and it can also be one of the causes of the drop in photographers’ motivation.

Photographers’ motivation issues

I’ve used Midjourney myself since I like keeping up to date with new technologies. This led me to some Facebook groups dedicated to text-to-image generators, and I’ve seen growing disappointment with how it affects photography. It’s becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish AI images from photos, making photographers lose motivation to share their work and submit it to contests. I am seeing growing apathy on the one hand and growing frustration and worry on the other. And I don’t like either.

 ai creative category photo contests frustration

Does AI have a place in photography contests?

I’ve been thinking about this a lot, and I always circle back to the same answer. In short, my answer is no. I’ve recently seen a bunch of articles and social media posts saying that “AI is not photography, and it never will be,” and my thought was always, “Well, thanks, Captain Obvious.” However, this doesn’t seem to be that obvious to contest judges, regardless of whether it’s SWPA or another competition.

To me, it’s really that obvious – an AI-generated image is not a photo. Sure, it was based on a gazillion photos that text-to-image generators used to feed their algorithm, but it’s still not photography. Even if you spent hours searching for the perfect prompt – nope, it’s still not photography.

In the “Creative” categories of photo contests, photographers submit photos they might have heavily edited and composited – but they still took them. As I mentioned above, your creations mustn’t contain any copyrighted material owned by a third party, so it’s still your photo you’re submitting – you just got creative with it.

 ai creative category photo contests portrait

Potential solutions

As I mentioned, I play with text-to-image generators (especially Midjourney), and it’s really fun. I even found it therapeutical in some cases, but that’s the topic for another day. So, I’m not trying to demonize AI image generators. I’m aware that they’re here to stay, so is there a way to incorporate the images they render into contests?

I think so. If we completely disregard the legal grey area for now, I think our AI creations should get a place to be displayed and awarded. There could be separate categories of photo contests dedicated to AI work. So, not the “Creative” category of the photography contest but a completely separate category. Also, the growing popularity of Midjourney and other AI tools opens room for new competitions that will be dedicated to AI-generated work only.

I just don’t think AI-generated work belongs within any photographic category because, as Captains Obvious of the Internet say: AI is not photography.

What do you think? Should AI work win photography contests? Should it be submitted in the first place, even in the “Creative” category?

FIND THIS INTERESTING? SHARE IT WITH YOUR FRIENDS!

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Related posts:

guide photo contests grants coverA comprehensive guide to photo contests and grants Sony World Photography Awards announces finalists of its 2021 Student and Youth contests On the depiction of Africans in photo contests 7 tips to follow when entering photography contests

Filed Under: Inspiration Tagged With: AI, Artificial Intelligence, Competition, contest, midjourney, photo competition, photography competition, photography contest, Sony World Photography Awards

Dunja Djudjic: from diyphotography.net

About Dunja Djudjic

Dunja Djudjic is a multi-talented artist based in Novi Sad, Serbia. With 15 years of experience as a photographer, she specializes in capturing the beauty of nature, travel, and fine art. In addition to her photography, Dunja also expresses her creativity through writing, embroidery, and jewelry making.

« James Webb takes perfect image of rings around Uranus
How to shoot the Michael Bay spinny hero shot in your own backyard »

Submit A Story

Get our FREE Lighting Book

DIYP lighting book cover

* download requires newsletter signup
DIYPhotography

Recent Comments

Free Resources

Advanced lighting book

Recent Posts

  • Here’s a bullet time video booth you can build yourself
  • Ricoh has discontinued the HD PENTAX-DA 21mm F3.2AL Limited silver lens
  • This “stellar flower” unravels the twilight’s evolution in 360 degrees
  • Strobes vs Continuous LEDs – Which is right for you?
  • Wave goodbye to Apple’s My Photo Stream next month

Udi Tirosh: from diyphotography.netUdi Tirosh is an entrepreneur, photography inventor, journalist, educator, and writer based in Israel. With over 25 years of experience in the photo-video industry, Udi has built and sold several photography-related brands. Udi has a double degree in mass media communications and computer science.

Alex Baker: from diyphotography.netAlex Baker is a portrait and lifestyle driven photographer based in Valencia, Spain. She works on a range of projects from commercial to fine art and has had work featured in publications such as The Daily Mail, Conde Nast Traveller and El Mundo, and has exhibited work across Europe

David Williams: from diyphotography.netDave Williams is an accomplished travel photographer, writer, and best-selling author from the UK. He is also a photography educator and published Aurora expert. Dave has traveled extensively in recent years, capturing stunning images from around the world in a modified van. His work has been featured in various publications and he has worked with notable brands such as Skoda, EE, Boeing, Huawei, Microsoft, BMW, Conde Nast, Electronic Arts, Discovery, BBC, The Guardian, ESPN, NBC, and many others.

John Aldred: from diyphotography.netJohn Aldred is a photographer with over 20 years of experience in the portrait and commercial worlds. He is based in Scotland and has been an early adopter - and occasional beta tester - of almost every digital imaging technology in that time. As well as his creative visual work, John uses 3D printing, electronics and programming to create his own photography and filmmaking tools and consults for a number of brands across the industry.

Dunja Djudjic: from diyphotography.netDunja Djudjic is a multi-talented artist based in Novi Sad, Serbia. With 15 years of experience as a photographer, she specializes in capturing the beauty of nature, travel, and fine art. In addition to her photography, Dunja also expresses her creativity through writing, embroidery, and jewelry making.

Copyright © DIYPhotography 2006 - 2023 | About | Contact | Advertise | Write for DIYP | Full Disclosure | Privacy Policy