DIY Photography

Your one stop shop for everything photo-video

  • News
  • Inspiration
  • Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • DIY
  • Gear
Search

Submit A Story

The problem with variable NDs and why fixed NDs are still relevant

Oct 2, 2017 by John Aldred 4 Comments

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Variable neutral density filters are quite a wonderful thing. In theory. They let you adjust your exposure outside of the camera’s own systems as the light on your scene changes. They’re quick and convenient, and expensive if you want a good one. But are they really all that good?

Lok Cheung used variable ND filters during his tenure at Digital Rev. He was typically the one manning the camera filming Kai. But since he’s gone solo, he’s noticed that they’re not really as practical as he’d like. Nor do they really offer the quality that one needs today. In this video, he explains why variable NDs just don’t hold up to the job, and why fixed NDs reign supreme.

Lok’s concerns with using a variable ND when filming his self were that he couldn’t easily adjust it when filming himself, plus crazy vignetting. Filming yourself is very different from filming other people. You’re relying on the camera a lot more than you normally would, for a start. Like Lok, when I’m filming other people, I’m fully manual all the way. When I’m filming myself, I’m often in some kind of automatic mode.

Lok puts his camera into shutter priority mode, letting the camera figure out the aperture and ISO to get a good exposure. Personally, I lock both the shutter speed and aperture and let the camera figure out the ISO. Variable ND filters can make both of these situations tricky, though. If you have to constantly adjust to let the camera get the optimal settings, it becomes a pain.

The obvious solution then is to simply set the variable ND at a given setting and let the camera figure it out, right? I mean, after all, that’s pretty much what you’re doing with a fixed ND filter. The problem there, though, is that when you stop many variable NDs down to 4 or 5 stops, you start to see some pretty heavy vignetting. There’s also weird cross-polarisation artifacts that happen with the ultrawide lenses typically used by vloggers.

And this is where fixed ND filters come in. You don’t get the vignetting or polarisation issues you do with variable NDs. They’re always consistent, they can’t be accidentally knocked to a different value or adjusted. And while they’re more of a pain to swap out and change to a different value, with today’s ISO performance, it’s not that big of a deal. Metering modes on recent camera models are also pretty good for video.

For stills… Well, variable NDs were designed more for quick adjustments on video rather than when shooting stills anyway. But for stills you’re going to have the same issues. Typically you’d use NDs when you want really long exposures of a few seconds or more. Often, that means landscapes, and landscapes usually means wide lenses. So, with variable NDs, you get the same cross polarisation issues that the vloggers experience.

I’ve always been a big proponent of fixed neutral density filters. They’re just so much more consistent, predictable and reliable than variable NDs. I do love my Schneiders. I did buy a variable ND filter, though. It seemed like a good idea at the time. It’s been on the end of my lens maybe twice since I got it.

Maybe variable ND filters will get there one day, but, for the most part, they’re not there yet.

FIND THIS INTERESTING? SHARE IT WITH YOUR FRIENDS!

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Related posts:

I wanted to see if K&F’s variable NDs can stand up to a regular neutral density filter Is the Canon EOS 90D relevant in the mirrorless cameras age? Poetry and Photography: How Rainer Maria Rilke Is Relevant To Being A Photographer Kathy Griffin attempts to stay relevant with tasteless decapitated Donald Trump photo shoot

Filed Under: Gear Tagged With: Lok Cheung, ND, ND filter, Neutral Density, Variable ND

John Aldred: from diyphotography.net

About John Aldred

John Aldred is a photographer with over 20 years of experience in the portrait and commercial worlds. He is based in Scotland and has been an early adopter - and occasional beta tester - of almost every digital imaging technology in that time. As well as his creative visual work, John uses 3D printing, electronics and programming to create his own photography and filmmaking tools and consults for a number of brands across the industry.

« How to fight creative jealousy… and get back to work
This photographer took a dancer to Iceland to test out the Canon 6D Mark II »

Submit A Story

Get our FREE Lighting Book

DIYP lighting book cover

* download requires newsletter signup
DIYPhotography

Recent Comments

Free Resources

Advanced lighting book

Recent Posts

  • Here’s a bullet time video booth you can build yourself
  • Ricoh has discontinued the HD PENTAX-DA 21mm F3.2AL Limited silver lens
  • This “stellar flower” unravels the twilight’s evolution in 360 degrees
  • Strobes vs Continuous LEDs – Which is right for you?
  • Wave goodbye to Apple’s My Photo Stream next month

Udi Tirosh: from diyphotography.netUdi Tirosh is an entrepreneur, photography inventor, journalist, educator, and writer based in Israel. With over 25 years of experience in the photo-video industry, Udi has built and sold several photography-related brands. Udi has a double degree in mass media communications and computer science.

Alex Baker: from diyphotography.netAlex Baker is a portrait and lifestyle driven photographer based in Valencia, Spain. She works on a range of projects from commercial to fine art and has had work featured in publications such as The Daily Mail, Conde Nast Traveller and El Mundo, and has exhibited work across Europe

David Williams: from diyphotography.netDave Williams is an accomplished travel photographer, writer, and best-selling author from the UK. He is also a photography educator and published Aurora expert. Dave has traveled extensively in recent years, capturing stunning images from around the world in a modified van. His work has been featured in various publications and he has worked with notable brands such as Skoda, EE, Boeing, Huawei, Microsoft, BMW, Conde Nast, Electronic Arts, Discovery, BBC, The Guardian, ESPN, NBC, and many others.

John Aldred: from diyphotography.netJohn Aldred is a photographer with over 20 years of experience in the portrait and commercial worlds. He is based in Scotland and has been an early adopter - and occasional beta tester - of almost every digital imaging technology in that time. As well as his creative visual work, John uses 3D printing, electronics and programming to create his own photography and filmmaking tools and consults for a number of brands across the industry.

Dunja Djudjic: from diyphotography.netDunja Djudjic is a multi-talented artist based in Novi Sad, Serbia. With 15 years of experience as a photographer, she specializes in capturing the beauty of nature, travel, and fine art. In addition to her photography, Dunja also expresses her creativity through writing, embroidery, and jewelry making.

Copyright © DIYPhotography 2006 - 2023 | About | Contact | Advertise | Write for DIYP | Full Disclosure | Privacy Policy