DIY Photography

Hacking Photography - one Picture at a time

  • News
  • Inspiration
  • Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • DIY
  • Gear
Search

 
@diyphotography

Telegram Me

Instagram

Submit A Story

Is it okay for street photographers to take photos of private messages?

Share
Tweet
July 6, 2018 by Dan Ginn 1 Comment

This week Business Insider ran a story that covered images taken by a street photographer, of people’s private phone messages. That photographer was the highly respected Jeff Mermelstein, someone who has a long list of celebrated work. Whilst all images were taken in public places, they do contain a level information that the subjects may not want the world to know about. Whilst no law has been broken, it could be argued that this is a lack of respect for a person’s privacy, raising the question – is it okay to photograph people’s private messages?

LAW VS ETHICS

Street Photography can be an extremely awkward art to practice. Whilst you may not break any laws, sometimes you will have to be in a position that may make the subject uncomfortable. That can be a difficult part of the craft for many street photographers, especially those just starting out. You have to get into a place where you are okay with any backlash that may happen, whether that be a funny look, or a little bit of verbal thrown your way. Whilst the latest amendments to GDPR has left many photographers confused about where they now stand legally, regardless of a person’s reaction, the general rule of the law is that if you are in a public place you can take all the wonderful artistic images that you wish to.

However there are ethics involved in street photography. Ethics that have been developed over the many decades that the art has been practised, and those who are serious about it tend to adhere to them. For example, we tend to stay away from photographing homeless people. We do not want to be seen as exploiting someone who is having such a rough time, when the only purpose is to make a photography that you think is super edgy and meaningful. Far more often than not, it is neither of the two.

In the case of Jeff Mermelstein, he has gone for something slightly different. He is delving into someone’s private world, whilst in a public setting – remaining in line with the law. Nearly all the subjects are not visible in the images, however in one picture it is possible to make out who the person is (if you know them) as their profile picture makes them identifiable. The topics of the text conversations vary from sex chat, talk of cancer, and regret from giving up a loved one. They are very intimate conversations, which I am sure the people having them believe to be completely contained between the two of them. Now these conversations are all over the internet. I’m sure if one of the subjects were to see them it would leave them feeling cheated, anxious and uncomfortable. Many of us, both inside and outside the community, blast the likes of Facebook for spying on us. If we see this technique as being acceptable, are we not just making ourselves part of the problem?

THE IMPACT ON STREET PHOTOGRAPHY

I have always found the opinion people have of street photographers to be varied. Some people despise us, whilst others are quite attracted to the idea of being considered a subject within a photographer’s content. In the case of Mermelstein, his project could make things tricky for the rest of us. We want street to be celebrated, understood and accepted. With privacy concerns growing and growing, could this put a dark cloud over the community as a whole?

Original article posted on Business Insider – This photographer captured shots of people texting their most intimate secrets in public – and it’s a compelling insight into human nature

About the Author

Dan Ginn is a London based photographer who likes to capture moments, the essence of people and life. If you’d like to check out his work, make sure to visit his website and follow him on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter. You can also read his blog on this link. This article was also published here and shared with permission.

[lead image by Daria Nepriakhina]

Share
Tweet

Related posts:

Is street photography killing itself? How to interact with strangers to get the most out of your street photography Photographers finds a couple he shot on the street after eight years to deliver their portrait These street photos perfectly illustrate what the Decisive Moment is

Filed Under: Inspiration Tagged With: Dan Ginn, secret message, street photographer, street photography, text messages

« Canon to launch two full frame mirrorless cameras in mid-2019
How to add shine and depth to hair in Photoshop in under a minute »
  • Markus

    Yet another street photographer who hides behind the law to act like a jerk and then calls it art. Society works in part because most people understand boundaries and respect boundaries. Mind your own business is a universal sentiment. If everyone acted like a creeper in public and called it art, society would be a more hostile place.

    The images aren’t even good or interesting. Oooh, blurry, grainy, digitally zoomed images of private people’s boring messages. I’m so glad these images exist so I can read peoples’ private messages without permission and satisfy my own inner creep.

Popular on DIYP

  • This unexpected Lightroom slider helps making perfect black and white conversions
  • This epic 81-megapixel moon photo was stacked from 50,000 images
  • Tamron to launch wide angle 17-28mm f/2.8 Zoom for Sony FE
  • These are the 10 best cameras for video under $300
  • Apple makes a Bokeh commercial, uses “bokeh” as a verb and pronounces it wrong
  • This guy bought a new Sony A6400 in an A6300 body
  • This viral video is the result of an angry Broadacres woman for shooting on public property
  • 2019 World Press Photo contest nominees will give you chills [NSFW]
  • Bowens really is back – and they’re made by Godox
  • Original raw Star Wars footage highlights the impact of good sound design – Also, Han totally shot first

Recent Comments


Previous Polls

Dunja Djudjic is a writer and photographer from Novi Sad, Serbia. You can see her work on Flickr, Behance and her Facebook page.

John Aldred is based in Scotland and photographs animals in the studio and people in the wild.

You can find out more about John on his website and follow his adventures on YouTube and Facebook.

JP Danko is a commercial photographer based in Toronto, Canada. JP
can change a lens mid-rappel, swap a memory card while treading water, or use a camel as a light stand.

To see more of his work please visit his studio website blurMEDIAphotography, or follow him on Twitter, 500px, Google Plus or YouTube.

JP’s photography is available for licensing at Stocksy United.

Clinton Lofthouse is a Photographer, Retoucher and Digital Artist based in the United Kingdom, who specialises in creative retouching and composites. Proud 80's baby, reader of graphic novels and movie geek!
Find my work on My website or follow me on Facebook or My page

Recent Posts

  • These Olympus commercials from the 1980s show that attitudes towards gear never really change
  • Samsung Galaxy S10 has three rear cameras and a dedicated Instagram photo mode
  • This 4.9mm Hyperfisheye prototype lens is so wide it can see behind itself
  • Adobe confused as to what a Nikon looks like – uses Fuji X-T20 to promote faster Nikon tethering
  • Soon you can use your Profoto modifiers on the Godox AD200 with the new AD-P adapter

Copyright © DIYPhotography 2006 - 2019 | About | Contact | Advertise | Write for DIYP | Full Disclosure | Privacy Policy