DIY Photography

Hacking Photography - one Picture at a time

  • News
  • Inspiration
  • Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • DIY
  • Gear
Search

Submit A Story

Follow up to Eyes of the Afghan Girl – A critical take on the “Steve McCurry Scandal”

Jun 10, 2016 by Kshitij Nagar 6 Comments

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Afghan-New-

While a follow up was already planned, after publishing the previous post and the subsequent, staggering response generated in support, appreciation, comments, critique and criticism I felt the need to also address certain things as well as perhaps reiterate and underline certain points. I also want to fill certain spaces left over in the previous post.

Let me begin again by reiterating that the previous opinion piece (and this follow up) is not an attack or attempt to defame Steve McCurry, it is only to throw light on certain aspects as well as bring some attention to the questions that plague visual journalism, especially in the past few years.

Firstly and most importantly, I would like to address and elaborate on the argument expressed on the eyes of the Afghan Girl and the apparent discrepancy in the two different published version. It was felt by many that the difference was too small to be highlighted, (which I expected).  I would like to argue that it may be small when comparing the actual size of the discrepancy, but not small when you take into account the history, context and gravitas of the image. The argument can also be extended further into into the impact of Afghan Girl image. Inferring that the overwhelming sympathy and support for young Malala Yousufzai, was perhaps somewhere, subconsciously linked to the impact of McCurry’s image when it was first published would not be wrong.

Left side image from the original cover, right side image from poster presently up for sale on Steve McCurry’s website.

Left side image from the original cover, right side image from poster presently up for sale on Steve McCurry’s website.

The missing, muck, dirt and glare from the caruncle eye is very much a part of the character of the Afghan Girl in the image when you see it from the point of view of journalism/ reportage whose ultimate goal is to provide the viewer with a slice of life to enter into and explore the scene and the story as the photographer felt and the way the camera captured it. Altering that slice of life is to begin to alter reality itself, irrespective of whom so ever does it, the photographer, the darkroom/studio assistant or the publisher.The muck and glare are as much a part of the life of a refugee girl living in a camp, across the Afghan desert in Pakistan as the dry lips and the torn head scarf.

Secondly on the issue of photoshopping images and it “not altering the narrative of the image” I would like to add that, poles, wires and clutter (rickshaw image from previous post) are very much a part of the chaotic daily life of India and the larger sub continent, thus very much a part of the image and of the narrative.

Thirdly, linking the two, the apparent discrepancy between the different versions of the Afghan Girl image, should not be looked at from the perspective of how easy it is to alter images in Photoshop now. The software was only introduced in 1990 (six years after the Afghan Girl image was published on the cover) and finally came directly into the hands of photographers much later with the advent of the digital era. Manual alterations have been done on prints (and then subsequently copied onto negatives/ slides from the prints) for quite a while.

To extend the argument further, I would like to bring W. Eugene Smith’s following image forward.

“Spanish Wake” – Deleitosa, Spain 1951, Photo by W Eugene Smith

“Spanish Wake” – Deleitosa, Spain 1951, Photo by W Eugene Smith

This photograph titled “Spanish Wake,” captured an intimate scene of the death of a villager in a spanish village.  LIFE magazine captioned it as the following- ” His wife, daughter, granddaughter and friends have their last earthly visit with a villager.”

This image was a part of Eugene Smith’s photo essay titled “Spanish Village,” published in LIFE magazine in 1951 which depicted live in a small rural village in Spain.

In actuality, in the original version that Smith photographed, two of the women (one identified as the widow of the person) had been looking into the camera and towards the photographer, delivering a completely different image. Later when printing the image in the darkroom Smith printed their eyes darker and applied bleach (most probably potassium cynide) with a fine-tipped brush to create new white areas, redirecting their eyes downward and thus altering the mood of the photo and ultimately making a completely different photograph. Later in 1956 Eugene Smith famously admitted to his use of staging and retouching in a gathering of American Society of Magazine Photographers.

FIND THIS INTERESTING? SHARE IT WITH YOUR FRIENDS!

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • WhatsApp

Related posts:

Eyes of the Afghan Girl – A critical take on the “Steve McCurry Scandal” Steve McCurry’s Assistant Arrested in $654,358 ‘Afghan Girl’ Art Theft Case Photojournalist Steve McCurry Recalls ‘Chaos’ at the Stade de France During Paris Attacks Renowned photojournalist Steve McCurry sits down for an insightful interview with Nikon

Filed Under: news Tagged With: Adobe Photoshop, Afghan Girl, controversy, Kshitij Nagar, Scandal, steve mccurry

« The timelapse bar has been raised once again with this amazing Singapore timelapse
Exploring this big wild world with my little cars »

Submit A Story

Get our FREE Lighting Book

DIYP lighting book cover

* download requires newsletter signup
DIYPhotography

Recent Comments

Free Resources

Advanced lighting book

Recent Posts

  • Sony’s ZV-E1 is a cut-down FX3 in a vlogging form factor
  • Watch: How good (or bad) is an $8.50 tripod?
  • How to light and photograph Lego building interiors
  • Lighting Setup: How to light your portraits with £50 LED tubes
  • Review: Insta360 announces its first gimbal – The AI-tracking Insta360 Flow

Alex Baker is a portrait and lifestyle driven photographer based in Valencia, Spain. She works on a range of projects from commercial to fine art and has had work featured in publications such as The Daily Mail, Conde Nast Traveller and El Mundo, and has exhibited work across Europe

Dave Williams is an accomplished travel photographer, writer, and best-selling author from the UK. He is also a photography educator and published Aurora expert. Dave has traveled extensively in recent years, capturing stunning images from around the world in a modified van. His work has been featured in various publications and he has worked with notable brands such as Skoda, EE, Boeing, Huawei, Microsoft, BMW, Conde Nast, Electronic Arts, Discovery, BBC, The Guardian, ESPN, NBC, and many others.

John Aldred is a photographer with over 20 years of experience in the portrait and commercial worlds. He is based in Scotland and has been an early adopter - and occasional beta tester - of almost every digital imaging technology in that time. As well as his creative visual work, John uses 3D printing, electronics and programming to create his own photography and filmmaking tools and consults for a number of brands across the industry.

Dunja Djudjic is a multi-talented artist based in Novi Sad, Serbia. With 15 years of experience as a photographer, she specializes in capturing the beauty of nature, travel, and fine art. In addition to her photography, Dunja also expresses her creativity through writing, embroidery, and jewelry making.

Copyright © DIYPhotography 2006 - 2023 | About | Contact | Advertise | Write for DIYP | Full Disclosure | Privacy Policy