DIY Photography

Hacking Photography - one Picture at a time

  • News
  • Inspiration
  • Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • DIY
  • Gear
Search

 
@diyphotography
Instagram

Submit A Story

Nude photographer sues National Trust for Scotland for damaging his reputation

Share23
Tweet41
+1

November 28, 2017 by Dunja Djudjic 3 Comments

Last year, photographer Howard Kennedy got under fire because of a nude photoshoot inside the 17th century Craigievar Castle. The National Trust for Scotland (NTS), who owns the castle, started an investigation after revealing the nude photos Kennedy shot inside of it. However, the photographer has now decided to fight back. Reportedly, he is suing NTS for damaging his personal reputation and seeks £50,000 in libel damages.

The Craigievar Castle is located in Aberdeenshire, Scotland. It was completed in 1626, and it’s been in the hands of NTS since 1963. It’s said to have inspired Walt Disney’s Cinderella Castle, but it seems it has also been an inspiring place for some nude shots. After Kennedy photographed the model Rachelle Summers in 2012, he and his wife Karen offered the prints for sale worldwide. In 2016, the images reached Gabriel Forbes-Sempill. She is the daughter of Lord Sempill, who gifted the castle to The National Trust. And this is where the whole saga began.

After MsSempill’s complaint, NTS denied granting Kennedy permission for the photoshoot. As Mirror reports, they stated that” “the Trust would never sanction photographs of this nature especially at a location that is regularly visited by families with children.” However, the photographer claimed that he had the permission to shoot, and even paid for it, although – there is no evidence.

As Kennedy told Daily Record, he’d booked the location over the phone: “I told them it was for nude photography. They wanted £500 but I said that was beyond my budget so we agreed £200.” He claims he handed over the check and shot the photos after getting the permission and paying.

Despite the photographer’s claims, NTS denied giving him the permission for the nude photoshoot. They started an investigation to find out how the photographer, his wife, and the model got into the castle. The spokesman confirmed they were “considering legal action against those responsible.”

After the claims of NTS have allegedly “damaged his professional reputation,” Kennedy has decided to sue them. He is seeking up to £50,000 ($66,500) in libel damages. According to the barrister, the complaint also caused around 50% drop in bookings of training courses which Kennedy runs. He adds that, due to the impact of the statement, Kennedy “was finding it extremely difficult to make commercial sales calls.” So, in addition to suing for libel damages, Kennedy is reportedly also suing for alleged breach of the Data Protection Act “including special damages for loss of business,” as reported in Mirror.

Here’s the barrister’s statement, as reported in Mirror:

“The present action concerns the circumstances surrounding Mr Kennedy’s attendance at one of the National Trust for Scotland’s properties, Craigievar Castle, in Aberdeenshire, on 23 February 2012, where he took a series of nude photographs of a model for commercial purposes.

“Mr Kennedy’s case is that he entered into an oral contract with NTS photo librarian, John Sinclair, on 21 February 2012, for the express purpose of shooting nude photographs of this nature.

“He further contends that NTS staff were fully aware of the specific nature of the photoshoot at the time, including via the oversight of at least one female member of staff, who is said to have supervised the photoshoot throughout, either in person or by way of CCTV.”

Reportedly, the case is scheduled for a later date. Considering there is no written evidence of the permission or payment, I am not sure how Kennedy will be able to prove his claims. But no matter how this case ends: I remind you to always make sure to get all the necessary permissions in writing.

[via FStoppers, Mirror, Image credits: Neil Williamson]

Share23
Tweet41
+1

Related posts:

Justin Bieber’s Defense For Running Over A Paparazzo: “He Refused To Move”, And I Don’t Blame Him B&H Photo to pay $3.22 million to settle discrimination case Nude app uses AI to detect and hide NSFW images from your phone Photographer sues Bruno Mars for sharing a childhood photo of himself on social media

Filed Under: news Tagged With: castle, Howard Kennedy, lawsuit, legal, nude photography, Nude Photos, scotland

« We took four models into the desert to create dramatic portraits in the landscape
Five free video editors that deliver professional level results »
  • Jools Parker

    That seems very odd, there’s a lot not being said here by both sides. If they cashed his cheque then he has proof that they entered into some form of agreement, and the NTS would be at fault for not ensuring paperwork was completed and any restrictions adhered to, though he’s a fool for not getting something in writing.

    • Daris Fox

      There’s also the fact that NTS and Historic Scotland have had long standing policies preventing any project from bring the property, owner or the trust into disrepute. Everyt ime a shoot takes place you’re supposed to fill out a shoot spec and brief for them for them to decide if it’ll go ahead (and quote a fee). They also enforce that policy quite vigorously in my experience, The fact (by all appearances) there is a lack of a paper trail brings it down to a verbal agreement which is worth nothing.

      He’s also using a no-win no-fee solicitor to chance his luck going by some media reports who are using rather tenuous grounds for defamation.

  • malcolmboura

    It is always very disappointing when a supposedly responsible organisation makes statement about nudity and families and children which are quite simply wrong. Children have no problem with nudity and knowing what the body really looks like is wholly beneficial.

Trending on DIYP

  • Wedding venue catches fire while filming the newlyweds’ first dance
  • The world’s first single shot 8×10 large format digital camera can be yours for a mere $106,000
  • This impossible long take was shot with a tiny drone in a Japanese high school
  • First look at the Pentax K1 Mark II and DFA 50mm f/1.4 lens
  • 2018 Pulitzer Prize winner for photography leaves his job and now works for a brewery

Recent Comments


Previous Polls

Dunja Djudjic is a writer and photographer from Novi Sad, Serbia. You can see her work on Flickr, Behance and her Facebook page.

John Aldred is based in Wishaw, Scotland and photographs animals in the studio and people in the wild.

You can find out more about John on his website or follow him on Facebook and YouTube.

JP Danko is a commercial photographer based in Toronto, Canada. JP
can change a lens mid-rappel, swap a memory card while treading water, or use a camel as a light stand.

To see more of his work please visit his studio website blurMEDIAphotography, or follow him on Twitter, 500px, Google Plus or YouTube.

JP’s photography is available for licensing at Stocksy United.

Clinton Lofthouse is a Photographer, Retoucher and Digital Artist based in the United Kingdom, who specialises in creative retouching and composites. Proud 80's baby, reader of graphic novels and movie geek!
Find my work on My website or follow me on Facebook or My page

Recent Posts

  • Learn Adobe After Effects with this new free course for beginners
  • Learn how to shape light with flags in under ten minutes
  • Capture One 11.1 update offers new workflow improvements and camera support
  • Canon launches Ivy; a rechargeable pocket-sized mini photo printer
  • Venus Optics soon to announce Laowa 10-18mm f/3.5-4.5 zoom lens for full frame cameras

Copyright © DIYPhotography 2006 - 2018 | About | Contact | Advertise | Write for DIYP | Full Disclosure