Exploring Small Strobes: Going Wireless

Exploring Small StrobesWelcome to this multi-part series of articles on Exploring Small Strobes by Yanik Chauvin from Yanik’s Photo School.

In part 1 on Exploring Small strobes, I looked at why using flash guns instead of the built-in flash and studio strobes. In part 2, I went through the importance of using your speedlight off camera.

What I’ll be going through today, in part 3, is looking at how to trigger and control your speedlights off camera; more specifically wirelessly. You’re probably saying to your self, it’s about time Yanik gets to the practical stuff! And you’re absolutely right! But I had to convince you first! ;-)

FOLLOW THIS SERIES OF ARTICLES!
BACK - Why Use Speedlights Off Camera
NEXT- Speedlight Accessories

Now, I could be writing a whole essay if I start going through every single manufacturer’s off camera lighting system. So for the purpose of this article, I’ll keep things generic so that off camera flashes will work on practically any camera system.

So, what could we use to wirelessly trigger our speedlights off camera? A wireless radio trigger! Logical my dear Watson! ;-) But wireless triggers are far from being equal, in both price and quality. So I’ll run them by with you pointing out the pros and cons of each one. Note that there are many companies making wireless triggers and I chose to highlight some of the most popular ones.

Why Wireless?

True, there are many ways to trigger your flash off-camera. If you got
so far, chances are you've gone through Strobist blog (twice) and you
know about sync wires and optical slaves. The fact is that when sync
cords work they are great, but there are so fragile and expensive that
going wireless is a big, big temptation.

The other option is optical slaving. This is a great solution for a
second flash. If you have an optical slave in your second flash (hint,
hint, SB26, SB800) you can use it to trigger that second flash based on
the pulse from the first flash. This is actually how many of the gridspot images were taken. So, we are back at square one -
triggering the first flash.

Pocket Wizards Plus II

First off, the big daddy of wireless remotes, the famous Pocket Wizard Plus II.

Pocket Wizard
Photo courtesy of Pocket Wizard

The PW is the trigger of choice for most professional photographers for many reasons but mostly because they never misfire (unless the batteries are dead ;)). When you’re getting paid to get that one perfect shot, you can’t afford to loose it because of a misfire. The other specs that photographers enjoy are:

  • 1600 feet range. WOW! That’s more than 5 football fields!
  • Line of site not required (can shoot through walls, etc)
  • 12 frames per second triggering speed
  • 4 selectable channels
  • All units are both transmitters and receivers (tranceivers)

On the “con” side, there isn’t much to say but there are 2 things that I’d like to point out:

  • They’re big and bulky compared to other triggers
  • Sync speed "only" 1/250 sec.
  • They’re the most expensive triggers out there at roughly $360 for the set

Cactus V2

I know I’m jumping from one extreme to the other but the Cactus triggers (a.k.a poverty wizards) are very popular among amateur and even some pros so mentioning it next just seemed logical. ?

Cactus V2
Photo courtesy of Gadget Infinity

Why are they so popular? Simple. The price. Retailing at only $32.95 for both the transmitter and receiver, it’s more than 10x cheaper than PWs. And they even throw in a flash stand.

The cons, based on photographer reviews, are as follows:

  • Occasional misfire or not firing
  • Limited range of 30 feet
  • Line of site cannot be obstructed
  • Cheap built (as to be expected)
  • Must remove transmitter from camera to change channels

For a quality/price ratio, you’re getting a very good deal. I think it’s the best unit to introduce beginners on a budget to wireless triggers. Also note that some clients received faulty triggers and had to return them to get new ones.

In between the Cactus V2 and the Pocket Wizard, you have a wide range of triggers that might fit your needs. Let’s look at 3 of them.

Elinchrom Skyports

Elinchrom Skyports
Photo courtesy of Elinchrom

Here’s a good mid range wireless trigger that has a lot more range than the Cactus V2. Let’s look at the pros and cons…

PROS:

  • Smaller than PWs
  • Up to 350 feet range outdoors and 160 feet indoors
  • Line of site not required (can shoot through walls, etc)
  • Sync speed up to 1/1000 sec
  • 8 selectable channels and 4 groups

CONS:

  • Fragile antenna
  • Build not as strong as PWs

This is a great mid range trigger and from the reviews I’ve read, quite reliable. If you don’t need to shoot a few football fields away than the Skyports might be a good option. You can the set for roughly $180.

CyberSyncs

CyberSyncs
photo courtesy of AlienBees

Cybersyncs are very similar to Skyports in many aspects. The design is different but most of the functions are similar.

PROS:

  • Smaller than PWs
  • Up to 350 feet range outdoors and 150 feet indoors
  • Line of site not required (can shoot through walls, etc)
  • 16 selectable frequencies

CONS:

  • Sync speed 1 stop slower than camera max sync speed
  • Test button can be activated in camera bag keeping unit on for 1 hour

Like the Skyports, the Cybersync is a good mid range trigger.You can the set for roughly $130.

Radio Poppers

Radio Poppers
Photo courtesy of Radio Popper

The Radio Popper P1 is quite new on the market but there’s lots of buzz around it within the strobist community. So what’s the big buzz? They are the first TTL and high sync speed enabled radio triggers. What does this mean, you might ask? Basically, what you can do with your current manufacturer’s infrared remote flash system (like the Nikon CLS), you can do with the Radio Popper… but with more reach.

PROS:

  • Up to 300 feet range
  • Line of site not required (can shoot through walls, etc)
  • Smaller than PWs
  • Works with Canon or Nikon TTL system

CONS:

  • Only tested for Nikon and Canon small flashes
  • Doesn’t work with studio strobes
  • Requires a “master” or “commander” flash to transmit
  • $360 for the set (same as PWs)

The reason I put the price in the “cons” is since they don’t work with studio strobes, you’ll need to purchase a different trigger for your studio which bumps up the costs.

There you have it! 5 different wireless radio triggers to choose from. Remember to look at your needs and your budget and purchase accordingly.

And if you think the PWs 1600 feet range isn’t enough for you, check out these DIY babies! Is 20 miles enough for ya! ;-)

On a side note, if you’re a Nikon user, you can check out my video on how to set up your CLS using your built-in flash.

In part 4 on Exploring Small Strobes, I’ll suggest different light modifiers for your small strobes.

Get Yourself a Strobe:


Yanik Chauvin is a professional photographer from
Ottawa, Canada. His main focus is on stock and commercial photography.
As a teacher with more than 10 years experience, he started Yanik’s Photo School as a way to give back to other passionate photographers.

Make sure you don't miss out on the next article - Register to the RSS feed or the newsletter.

Comments

Power source on radio triggers ...

PW uses standard AA batteries.
Cactus uses small, but "expensive", batteries
Skyport receivers have internal Li-Ion batteries, which can't be changed.
Don't know about rest.
This might be something that doesn't make any difference to most of readers, but at the sametime, it might be something that eliminates some candidates from list.

great!

i want one of these soooo bad.

Radiopopper Jr

Let's not forget the Radiopopper Jr, which seems pretty promising whenever it's developed and launched. Cheap and solid.

flash triggers

Hi there, great article but i miss these triggers, which are pro quality, but cost only 1/2 of the famous top of the line ones, they are called flashwaves and i use them with pleasure.

http://g9chon.com/RS.html

cheers
Marco

Cactus mod

The popularity of Cactus V2 implies one more "pro" argument : the community published a *lot* of mods, particulary adding external antenna or a AA (or AAA as you wish) batteries holder, which then can be use with rechargeable).

For exemple, adding an antenna has increase outdoor range from 15m to 170m (550 feet) !!

PW Sync speed "only" 1/250

PW Sync speed "only" 1/250 sec NOT TRUE!

1/250 with a D200/D300 etc. But with a D70 you can reach 1/1000

CyberSync max sync speed

Alienbees does suggest a max sync speed 1/3 or 2/3 stop less than the camera's max sync. In practice I've found that the camera's max sync speed works (1/250 on Canon 20D, 1/500 on Canon G7).

With the electronic shutter of the G7, I'm limited to max sync speed (to get full flash exposure) at 1/1 on a Speedlite but at lower flash power (thus shorter duration) I can push the shutter speed higher. 1/4 power works at 1/1250 for example.

The caution about sync speed may be related to use of their studio flash, where flash durations at very low power can approach camera sync speed.

@ Anonymous Thanks for the

@ Anonymous
Thanks for the link on the Flashwaves... I'll check them out.

@ Pestbarn
Yup. Looking forward to the RP jr.

@ Juha
Good point! Batteries could be important to some readers. Thanks for sharing!

Radoipoppers and Pentax

Seems the Radiopoppers work on Pentax as well, even though not officially supported:

Even cheaper "Cactus"

Small hint: If you don't shy away from a two week delivery time, Paypal'ing money to china, and don't need the PC sync port, you can have your beginner's wireless setup for even less than the Cactus triggers. The company that apparantly produces the Cactus triggers is called "YongNuo" and a small Hong Kong based online shop named DealExtreme will gladly send them to you for US$19.95 with no additional postage. It's already the new version that comes with standard AAA battery compartment for the receiver and works with Canon's EX flash series. I am very satisfied with the item, it works exactly as advertised: http://www.dealextreme.com/details.dx/sku.13089

Their site also features an even newer version of wireless triggers I don't have any first-hand experience with:
http://www.dealextreme.com/details.dx/sku.16068

First you should note the

First you should note the newest Cactus is the V2s model. These differ from the V2 model that has some issues with certain flashes.

Also with the Cactus set, line of site is not required (can shoot through walls, etc). They use a radio frequency just like the others.

New to strobes

I'm kinda new to using strobes (I mainly use natural light) and i was wondering if anyone can clarify things for me. I have an old Fujica 300x strobe ('85) that's probably not going to be compatible with any of these wireless triggers. So what does that mean? Will it still trigger the flash?

I use a Olympus c-8080 in case that changes things.

Flash Waves

All things considered I went through the process 3 or 4 months ago and ended up getting a set of Flash waves. For me and my requirements they represented the best value for money.

They have proved to be reliable and work well.

You can see my reasoning in this article - Radio Flash Triggers

mistake...?

I recently bought the canon st-e2 transmitter to fire my speedlites off camera. I'm surprised not to see them mentioned here... Now I'm concerned I made a mistake.

Any comments?

re: not at all

Cannon makes great equipment. however, this review was focused on generic systems. rest assure, you bought well. The only minus is that if you ever cross over to the "yellow" side, you;ll need new triggers.

The  st-e2 also packs some nice Canon only features like TTL and ratio control.

Sony and triggers

I know the big camera manufactures are Canon and Nikon but, what about Sony?! I have a Sony Alpha 200 and the selection of triggers for it seems rather small... I have heard that the Alienbees will work but, what about the PW or any of the other brands mentioned so far? Any suggestions??

Please help!!!

I hope with Sony coming out with the recent Alpha A900 that more companies will take notice and make more available products for us!
*crosses fingers*

Most of these products are

Most of these products are NOT designed for a specific brand of camera. I can take the Pocket Wizards or Cactus triggers and use them on any camera. As long as the camera has a hot shoe. The transmitter fits into the hot shoe, and the receiver attaches to the flash. I have used the same Cactus triggers with Olympus, Nikon, and Canon cameras.

With a Sony Alpha mount one of the above transmitters to your camera's hot shoe, and a receiver to a Nikon or Canon Flash, and fire the flash. A lot of Canon shooters, use Nikon speedlights this way. I used to have a variety of Nikon and Canon flashes, that I fired simultaneously using the transmitter mounted on an Olympus DSLR.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <a>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options