Crowdsourcing Bullet Time
Eeeeveryboy loves Bullet Time. Bullet Time is that magical moment in a movie when everything freezes and the camera makes a circle or a semi circle around an object. I guess it is called bullet time cuz the camera moves at the speed of a bullet.
By now, you probably know that this effect is achieved with a battery of stills camera that will set you back a small house. To achieve Bullet Time, the photographers (or Bullet time specialist) places cameras in a circle and use both a green screen and clever triggering software.
The big number of cameras are used to maintain smooth motion as the point of view moves from one camera to another.
The Triggering mechanism is used to trigger the camera one after the other in very close succession, so it would seem like time is still flowing while the POV changes.
And the green screens is used to eliminate any interference and gain control over the set.
Or..... You could crowd source it all.
Photographer Guy Viner really wanted to make a Bullet Time sequence but lacked the 24+ DSLRs that would be needed to pull of this stunt. (He also lacked the 60 feet of green screen and the software), Instead he called some friends. Before we go into the details, here is what they pulled off.
Kicking Off The Project
The first hurdle was getting the 20+ cameras that this project would require. So a few months back Guy put a call on his blog and 24 photographers showed up to a local photography club meeting.
The initial results which you can see in the video above were promising, so a second date was set, and this time it was during a photography convention which promised a bigger scale production. The movies below are from the earlier attempt and a bigger, better movie is on the way.
Challenge 1 - Cameras
While the hardest part of getting a few dozen photographers (and cameras) involved was successful accomplished, the crowdsourcing part of the project yielded a few technical issues that needed to be addressed.
What, didn't you all showed up with a 60D and a 50mm 1.8? Well, no. within the 43 photographers there was a huge range of cameras, tripods and lenses. This meant, different base ISOs, different focal lenses and distortions, different maximal and minimal tripod length, different color hues - well, you get the point. (click the image to see a bigger version of the mess)
The first thing to do was get everyone into position. A white ping-pong ball was hanged where the action would take place and a rope was used to create a circle. Tripods were carefully set at the edges of the circle from low to high, creating an arch. The ball was then used both for focusing and calibration.

To overcome the messy camera situation, a few settings were set and a ping pong ball was shot. To get everyone on the same line, all ISO, white balance, and aperture were manually set. Focal length was set at 55mm since it seemed to be common enough.
A shot of a white ping pong ball carefully placed at where the subject would be. The nice thing about ping pong balls is that they look the same from every angle, so it can be used to calibrate the cropping and align the images of the action sequence photographs. (simply place ball over ball, I know it sounds bad, but, really, this is how it works).

Challenge 2 - Synchronization
It's hard to sync 43 cameras. Dedicated software like DSLR Remote Pro Multi-Camera can trigger tens of cameras in sync, yet we were dealing with a low-cost setup. This is why we opted to not precisely synchronize the cameras. A long exposure of 5 seconds was used on all cameras (good enough so everyone can open shutters) and 2 SB900 strobes will provide a lighting quick exposure.
Since the only light will be coming from the strobes there is no risk at having the shutters open in slightly different timing.
But, how will the strobes know when to fire? A cameraAxe with a sound trigger was used to pick up the sound of the popping balloon and trigger the strobes.

Challenge 3 - Environment Control
As I mentioned before we had no green screen to control the environment, so two measures were taken to assure control.
We had everything done in complete darkness so the background would be black. The only light came from a small flashlight signaling the photographers to open shutters, and once all clicks were heard, the actors know they had about 3 more seconds to pop the balloon.
The second measure was to point the cameras slightly upwards. This ensured that camera will not pick up the photographer on the other side. This kind of cross fire avoidance will not hold for a shooting range, but definitely works for a Matrix style bullet time.
Walking The Scene
And if all that was not enough, the nice guys over at Rotary View made a 3D controllable slider for it:
Conclusion
I know lots of you guys don't own 20 camera (even Joe McNally travels with dozens of strobes, but probably not more than a few bodies). If you are a part of a photography club or a group, this is just the kind of project that you could put up in one afternoon or a rainy day. Please share your results if you do anything like this.
Get the DIYP greatness via RSS, newsletter and Twitter
Connect with the community: Facebook Page, Discussions
Share Ideas, Setups, Images and Projects on DIYP's Flickr, visit Readers Photos



Comments
WOW
Guy Viner is one of the most interesting photographers I've ever met.
The guy (Guy...ha...ha...ha...) is a crazy @#$%%^...
;-)
holy crap!
This is just too awesome! thansk for sharing.
its called bullet time
because of the bullet that scratched neos shoulder in the most famous in the matrix
another reason is that this technique is made to capture fast things in action, fast like a bullet...
Using Infrared Triggers....
Udi: This is such an awesome concept, and the execution is really quite well done! I look forward to more "bullet time" videos from Guy.
One possible way to refine the technique used here would be to have an infrared remote as a triggering device. Many of the Nikon CoolPix and DSLR's can be fired off with proprietary (and after-market) triggers, and I believe that the D70, D90, and D7000 all have infrared sensors. Perhaps a gathering of Nikon users could be put together to make another sort of bullet time video...
The benefit to using a infrared triggering device is that this technique could be used with fast shutter speeds -- even in broad daylight. Just a thought.
Matt
re: nikon shooters and IR remotes
Hi Matt,
That is a very interesting line of thought. I am pretty sure this may work if all cameras have everything preset. (and using an all Nikon team will definitely un-comlex the crop factor from the equation).
As for the 24 shooters. Make this 23 :) I have a Nikon
You would need to find 24 photographers who shoot Nikon
You would need to find 24 photographers who shoot Nikon, Not sure this is a possible task ;)
Finding 24 Nikon Shooters...
Jeff: Indeed... Finding 24 photographers who own Nikon cameras would be a very, very difficult challenge.
thanks
i think the ir remote wont work cuz every camera has her own shutter lag...
IR remote
you're definitely right guy! even from the same make, the shutter may not fire at the same exact time.. not to mention how to sinchronize the bursting water baloon that happens in split second.
at first I thought the shutter was set on B, but seems 5 sec was enoght. excellent work guy! can't wait to see the longer version :)
uhhh, the writer's intro to
uhhh, the writer's intro to this piece is largely incorrect. the cameras need to all be synced to fire at the same time, not in succession - that is what makes the illusion and the freeze. and you don't have to have a green screen when it is done with a semi-circle or straight line of cameras pointed at the subject. only need a circle if you want to travel all the way around the frozen subject (thus needing a green screen).
the "movement" is the illusion created when you show the frames from each camera in sequence. The camera "moves" around a frozen object (like a bullet).
the name came from the matrix and using it in the shots where he is frozen and the bullets move past him - it is a "time" slowed down so we can see a bullet moving. the bullet in the movie is CG but the freezing of the people movement was done using the semi-circle of cameras all firing at once technique.
Re-correction
The name did come from the Matrix, as an earlier commenter posted. However, the cameras are not triggered simultaneously. They are triggered sequentially (you can see this in the Matrix special features). That is why Neo moves during the shot. He is not frozen. Both he and the bullet are in motion (although the bullet is CG as you pointed out).
Awesome!
I've been having some discussions with Guy about this for awhile now. He really is a top notch photographer and a great creative mind. I'm actually putting together my own video based on this technique from Guy. It will probably be ready in a few days at www.techphotoblog.com. It's really awesome that diyphotography.net picked this up. I think it's one of the neatest uses I've seen with the Camera Axe.
I think both sides are correct in the discussion above about the IR links (though personally use cables instead of an IR remove) and whether a shot can tollerate the shutter lag. It really depends on what types of shots you're going for. I think Guy's approach is probably the easiest when croud sourcing and the reasults are amazing. On the other had I've been talking with George (http://www.hatzakisphotography.com/Bullet_time.html) about hardware setups that would alow him to trigger cameras directly and even do slight offsets between each camera instead of actually triggering all the cameras at the same time. This would give a slow motion pan of a high speed event.
re: bullet time
heya Maurice,
always great when you drop by. thank you so very much for George's work link. his stuff is amazing.
Bullet time
The term bullet time is actualy for the game Max Payne and adopted by the matrix.
If you are going to be an ass, get your facts straigth.
The game max payne released
The game max payne released in 2001. the first matrix movie in 1999. i think you need to get your facts straigth.
using the Rotary View player
Did anyone try to use this player here?
Rotaryview player
Its realy easy , just try it you will see
Awesome! Thank you for
Awesome!
Thank you for sharing!
Crowdsourcing Bullet Time
I quite like the concept of this and learnt about Camera Axe, I'm looking at do something around a timelapse based crowedsource project, see how it goes and post resultes when it happens.
I would also like to share this site Digital Air they show you the different setups for time slice or bullet time and other options. Great reading for this seasonal period and really happy to share http://www.digitalair.com/techniques/
Pure awesome!
Thank you for sharing!
Post new comment